Discussion:
Expanding _PATH_DEFPATH
Jilles Tjoelker
2015-12-24 23:13:49 UTC
Permalink
In <paths.h> there is a #define _PATH_DEFPATH which is set to
/usr/bin:/bin. This does not include /sbin, /usr/sbin and ports
(/usr/local/bin and /usr/local/sbin) directories and is therefore often
insufficient.

This is rarely a problem because _PATH_DEFPATH is overridden by
/etc/login.conf, ~/.login_conf and/or shell startup files. _PATH_DEFPATH
is still used as a default by execlp(), execvp(), posix_spawnp() and sh
if PATH is not set, and by cron.

Especially the latter is a common trap (most recently in PR 204813). We
can fix it for 99% by changing _PATH_DEFPATH to
/sbin:/bin:/usr/sbin:/usr/bin:/usr/local/sbin:/usr/local/bin
This is the path in the default class in the default /etc/login.conf,
excluding ~/bin which would not be expanded properly in a string
constant.

For consistency, the _PATH_DEFPATH for RESCUE below and in 3 man pages
(exec.3, posix_spawn.3, crontab.5) need to be adjusted as well.
--
Jilles Tjoelker
Alfred Perlstein
2015-12-25 07:42:03 UTC
Permalink
Post by Jilles Tjoelker
In <paths.h> there is a #define _PATH_DEFPATH which is set to
/usr/bin:/bin. This does not include /sbin, /usr/sbin and ports
(/usr/local/bin and /usr/local/sbin) directories and is therefore often
insufficient.
This is rarely a problem because _PATH_DEFPATH is overridden by
/etc/login.conf, ~/.login_conf and/or shell startup files. _PATH_DEFPATH
is still used as a default by execlp(), execvp(), posix_spawnp() and sh
if PATH is not set, and by cron.
Especially the latter is a common trap (most recently in PR 204813). We
can fix it for 99% by changing _PATH_DEFPATH to
/sbin:/bin:/usr/sbin:/usr/bin:/usr/local/sbin:/usr/local/bin
This is the path in the default class in the default /etc/login.conf,
excluding ~/bin which would not be expanded properly in a string
constant.
For consistency, the _PATH_DEFPATH for RESCUE below and in 3 man pages
(exec.3, posix_spawn.3, crontab.5) need to be adjusted as well.
I have stubbed toes against this silly restricted path so many times
that this would be a welcome change.

However before changing the PATH please consult secteam to make sure
it's safe.

I might recommend for the time being going with the suggestion in the PR
which asks that a friendly note be added to files. This would be more
"safe" until secteam can analyze.

-Alfred

Loading...